Work
About
Contact
Close Menu Icon

CASE STUDY

Tiered Membership Pages

ABS-CBN Foundation International

Photo of the membership landing page showing an overview of available donation tiers with clear call-to-action buttons and visual hierarchyDetailed view of a single donation tier, highlighting benefits and monthly contribution options with clean, user-friendly layoutSide-by-side comparison of all membership tiers, outlining key features, price points, and differences in a structured format

From One-Time Giving to Ongoing Impact: Redesigning AFI's Donor Experience

My role: UX designer on a 2-person team
Timeline: 3 months
Focus: Layout design, visual hierarchy, and user flow optimization

The Challenge

ABS-CBN Foundation International (AFI) faced a common nonprofit problem: their donation system generated one-time contributions during crises but failed to build lasting supporter relationships. The existing system was a basic PayPal checkout where users entered any amount. There was no structure, no incentives to return, and no pathway for deeper engagement.

Key Problems Identified:

My Design Process

Research and Analysis

Working alongside a senior designer, I researched how leading nonprofits structure their giving programs. I analyzed Save the Children and Oxfam's checkout pages, focusing on how they used color coding to help users quickly identify which programs their donations supported. I also studied their use of visual elements during checkout to keep users motivated and connected to the cause.

For the membership tier structure, I examined KQED's layout approach to understand how to present multiple giving levels clearly and accessibly.

Design Solution: Three-Tiered Membership Structure

Pages I Owned:

Membership Landing Page

I designed the entry point that reframes donations as membership and belonging. Below the hero section, I created a "How Membership Works" section with three clear steps: choose a program, donate, connect with community. Program cards use the existing site's card pattern create visual consistency through the entire flow.

Photo of the membership landing page showing an overview of available donation tiers with clear call-to-action buttons and visual hierarchySide-by-side comparison of all membership tiers, outlining key features, price points, and differences in a structured table format

Membership Tiers Comparison Page

This was the page I'm most proud of. The challenge was presenting complex information—multiple tiers with cascading benefits—without overwhelming users.

My Layout Strategy:

  • Used an F-scan pattern layout with three sections (one per tier)
  • Created asymmetrical two-column design within each section
  • Left column: Large tier name with smaller descriptive blurb underneath
  • Right column: Benefits list with familiar icons for quick scanning
  • Selected icons from existing library based on universal meanings (chat bubbles for community forum, envelope for newsletter, shopping bag for merchandise)
  • Aligned icons directly with benefits titles for maximum legibility
Detailed view of a single donation tier, highlighting benefits and monthly contribution options with clean, user-friendly layoutDetailed view of a single donation tier, highlighting benefits and monthly contribution options with clean, user-friendly layout

Visual Hierarchy Decisions:

I constantly tested the page by blurring it and looking what caught my attention first, then adjusted typography, spacing, and contrast to ensure the most important information (tier names and key benefits) stood out immediately.

Detailed view of a single donation tier, highlighting benefits and monthly contribution options with clean, user-friendly layout

Individual Tier Pages

For users who wanted deeper program information before converting, I designed detailed pages showcasing membership benefits beyond financial contribution, such as exclusive events, community access, and field updates. These pages transform the transaction into a relationship-building opportunity.

Final step in the membership sign-up process, displaying selected tier, payment fields, and accessible form design for smooth donation completion

Color-Coding System

I developed a consistent color system used across program cards and throughout the checkout process. Colors were chosen using color theory principles aligned with program focus areas (green for environment, blue for education) while staying within AFI's brand palette. This created clear visual connections between program selection and donation, reducing confusion about where contributions were directed.

Final step in the membership sign-up process, displaying selected tier, payment fields, and accessible form design for smooth donation completionFinal step in the membership sign-up process, displaying selected tier, payment fields, and accessible form design for smooth donation completion

Streamlined Conversion Flow

Button Strategy: Each program card includes two paths based on user intent:

  • "Join Our Community" - direct path to membership sign-up
  • "Learn More" - route to detailed program information first

This dual-path approach acknowledges that users have different information needs before converting while keeping both options immediately accessible.

Final step in the membership sign-up process, displaying selected tier, payment fields, and accessible form design for smooth donation completion

Design Desicions and Rationale

Card-Based Layout: Chose cards to amintain consistency with the existing website design language, making the new pages ffeel integrated rather than disconnected.

F-Pattern Layout: Deliberately structured the tier comparison to work with natural reading patterns, placing the most important information (tier names) in high-attention areas.

Icon Selection: Prioritized universal recognition over custom design to reduce cognitive load during the scanning process.

Color Psychology: Used strategic color choices to create intuitive connections between program types and visual identifiers, making navigation and selection more intuitive.

Dual Conversion Paths: Recognized that users approach giving decisions differently (some want immediate action, others need more information) and designed to serve both preferences without friction.

Collaboration and Process

Throughout the project, I focused on layout design and visual hierarchy while receiving feedback and strategic direction from the senior designer. Our collaborative research informed my design decisions, but the execution of layouts, visual systems, and user flow optimization was my primary responsibility.

Impact and Reflection

The new membership model creates clear pathways for supporter growth and transforms AFI's approach from reactive crisis fundraising to sustainable, relationship-based giving. The design centers trust, flexibility, and clarity, turning what was once a simple PayPal form into a comprehensive membership experience.

This project reinforced how thoughtful layout and visual hierarchy decisions can transform not just user experience, but the entire relationship between an organization and its supporters. Design became the bridge between one-time transactions and lasting impact.